The discovery of vaccine

From Champfleury’s Histoire de la caricature sous la République, l’Empire et la Restauration (Paris, 1877). Any revolution unfortunately generates excess, any excess is paid for by steps backward. It has been so since the beginning of humanity and it will always be the same, the Progress or Decadence of nations being exercised only imperceptibly and via slow permeations. That a people erect a pyramid at the top of which it engraves the main facts of its history, that a crevasse opens revealing the abyss at the bottom of which a nation is condemned to expiate its faults, long years will pass before the last stone of the commemorative monument is laid, before the collapse in which men and things must disappear.

Many volumes have been written on this theme and had the title page adorned with solemn gentlemen thinkers gaunt as wineskins. The author [Champfleury], predisposed by his studies to fear mockery, considers it appropriate to leave aside the grandeur of the decline of empires as well as banal historical forecasts. His more modest role consists in seeking what futile repercussions sometimes lead to serious events. So one could, according to him, draw a picture of satirical ephemerides relating to important discoveries, to the benefits that humanity accepts only with a mocking smile.

In this order, the century opens with the discovery of vaccine. As soon as Jenner’s name is mentioned, the cartoon catches your eye. “Were the discovery of vaccine,” said Cuvier in a report to the Institut de France, “to be the only thing that medicine had obtained in the present period, it would suffice to forever illustrate our era in the history of science.” But just as there are mockingbirds which parody the song of the nightingale, so also people who practice mockery never lose their rights. They are useful, moreover, helping to popularize a discovery, although their pencil is not cut out for this purpose The discovery of vaccine was therefore set upon by cartoonists, without giving them a strong inspiration.

French hygiene cartooon

Quarantined

Young John Scattercash (who has been on board the “Brisbane”) is run to earth at a grand supper, given in celebration of his sister’s wedding, and taken off to quarantine.
(Sydney Punch, 1877)
(When Sir Arthur Kennedy, newly appointed as governor of Queensland, arrived on the steamer Brisbane from Hong Kong in March 1877, a “Chinaman” on board was found to be infected with smallpox. The ship and its hundreds of Chinese passengers were held in quarantine in Moreton Bay, but the political authorities dithered about whether Kennedy and his entourage should be exempted. A special medical commission was created to adjudicate, but this was widely dismissed as merely buying time to downplay a potentially unpopular decision that would be, at root, political. “The people of Australia are looked upon in England as being a trifle too democratic, as inclined to pay too little respect to high rank or exalted dignity,” proclaimed The Brisbane Courier. “It is reserved for the Imperial authorities to lower the state which has always been accorded to the Governor of Queensland, by sending us one, traveling to assume his Government, as a passenger on a merchant steamer crowded with hundreds of Chinese coolies… We have, however, a decided right to object to any relaxation of the precautions usually deemed necessary to prevent the landing of smallpox on our shores.” According to Krista Maglen, Australia favored quarantine as a tool of disease prevention well after Britain had abandoned this tactic, and not only for reasons of geographical isolation. This image makes clear the strong resonances with questions of class which quarantine also excited.)

Australian quarantine cartoon

For sanitary reasons

Presiding magistrate: “You are accused of stealing silver spoons. Can you offer any extenuating circumstances?”
Accused: “Yes. I did it for sanitary reasons.”
Presiding magistrate: “For sanitary reasons?”
Accused: “Because of the cholera. I had a cholera concoction made for myself, and the doctor said that it would be effective only if I took a tablespoon every two hours. And that’s what I did.”
(Appenzeller Kalender, Zurich, 1877)

Swiss cholera cartoon